
Upon seeing it my wife said, “Oh! Wow! That really says a lot! . . . That style of worship is really all about showing what a good Christian a person is.”
There is no question that it is a show. There is no question as to whom the show draws attention.
This really is an important contrast between what is often labeled “Praise and Worship” or “Contemporary Worship” and the historic liturgical worship of the Church catholic. The focus of the “show” is truly very, VERY different.
In connection with this it is appropriate to ask why the difference is chosen. Why do so many choose the enthusiastic emphasis and reject the liturgical focus?
The answer is quite clear. In the Praise and Worship choice the focus is on the individual. The Worship is then about Me and My faith and My love for Jesus and My commitment and My zeal and My . . .
The attention is on Me and My worship.
Thus today, many churches offer a variety of choices, to satisfy individual tastes. In many churches today the menu includes such choices as “Contemporary,” “Traditional,” and “B lended” worship selections. Within the same congregation three different styles of worship are offered to satisfy the felt needs of the various members. Truly the focus is on My worship. “What do I want My worship experience to be?”
In the historic liturgy of the Church the focus is very different. In all aspects of the divine service the focus is upon the Lord and His means of grace by which He comes to His Church as those who have been called together by His Holy Spirit to be one congregation gathered for one divinely appointed purpose, to receive the life that He gives through His means of grace. From beginning to end, every word of the service has this as its focus. In the historic liturgy, each individual is directed away from his own actions and desires and thoughts so as to see and hear and taste the holy, perfect, and loving actions and desires and thoughts of the Lord. Every action of the pastor is carefully crafted to direct the people's hearts and minds away from themselves to the Lord and what He is doing for His people. Moreover, the actions of the congregation are united in common confession and hymnody. No particular person is singled out, not even the pastor. All attention is upon the Lord and His acts of mercy and love. In the divine liturgy no discrimination exists. Every person is treated exactly the same, regardless of age or beauty or wealth or apparel or abilities. Even the historic vestments of the pastor are designed to say that he is not the focus, not his skills, not his appearance, not his personality.
Truly there is a difference in the focus of these two approaches and understandings of worship.
Interestingly, in the churches that offer a variety of styles, there is not a variety of focus. For with the offering of choice in the service, the only focus is the disintegrative focus of selfishness. Each person is doomed to focus only upon self and to rely upon one's own decision and commitment.
This is a real tragedy. For the Lord calls His Church to be one in Him. In Him there is no discrimination. The only discrimination experienced in the liturgy is the separation that God works through Baptism, in separating the called unto Himself to stand apart from the world, gathered into the unity of His Holy Communion.
When I come to the divine service, I give thanks that the focus is not on me and my sinfulness. Rather, God's merciful love is poured out from beginning to end, and the peace of God that surpasses all understanding guards and keeps me with all the saints in Christ Jesus. I cannot understand why any informed person would choose anything else.